So we are supposed to get a metric ton of snow this weekend, which is a good thing for me as I can plant my butt in a chair and work on some projects. Well, I plan to make some serious headway on the Fantasy Firearms project and so I decided to organize the art I have for the project into a single folder. In conjunction with that I decided to go look for some high quality stock art for the project to mix in with the for-hire stuff I have.
[Begin Rant]
After wading through the dozens and dozens of pages of utter crap that fills the Publisher Resources section, along with scrolling past all the 3D generated uber-babes, I did manage to find a few likely prospects. But so many of them did not show you what you are buying it rapidly degenerated into a crap shoot. If you have a Stock Art selection of magic items, or armor or whatever, why in the *fcuk* can’t I see a thumbnail of the image? Seriously, you want me to spend my money on artwork *THAT YOU WILL NOT SHOW ME*? Who thinks thats a good idea? How about you show me what I am getting like Shamman’s Stock art or the Image Portfolio line or even my very own stock art offerings the Skortched Urf’ Studios Sketchbook line? But no, instead I had to waste my time sifting through the crap, checking licences and squinting at near-microscopic thumbnails.

I spent damn near three hours last night sifting stock art. Did I find some useful art? Yes, I actually did. But it was far harder than it should have been.
So, rather than just bitch about the current state, I figured I would offer a few suggestions…
If you sell stock art; please for the love of all that is Holy include a good preview or thumbnail! Preferably embedded in the listing itself rather than some external file or other means that will take me away from the listing. The RPGNow flip book is ideal, or a large image as Shamman’s stock art uses would be fine. While your at it, it would be a good idea to include the license terms *in the sales listing* so we know what we can and can’t do with it once we purchase it. Can I color it? Can I modify it? Must I include your logo inside the image? These are important considerations to a publisher, and we prefer not to be surprised after we have dropped the money.
I have no real problem with the 3D generated stock art. I especially like it for vehicles, guns and other things with sharp edges. But I also feel it needs to be seperated out inside the stock art category. I don’t want to use 3D stock art in my projects, so why must I scroll through pages and pages of it to find what I am really after? I think we need to add some sub-categories in the Publisher Resources section. I found fonts, page templates, cover templates, illustrations and 3D art all lumped in together. I also found some very cool images that were not stock art, but intended only for private use in games. I’m glad the publisher was careful to mention that in the sales listing, but a seperate category other that the broad Publisher Resources is in order. I would suggest sub-categories like Full Color Stock Art, B&W Stock Art, 3D Stock Art, Fonts, Design Elements, Personal Use Stock Art (i.e. not for publishers but for your GM to use), and a catch all Other Publisher Resources to round it out.
Let’s talk about quality for a second. Some of the art for sale is, quite frankly, so bad that I felt it came out of a middle school kids sketchbook. Seriously, do you really think people are going to buy this:

or this…

I’m not trying to be mean, but seriously how many of these do you think have sold? I know we all want to make a few bucks, but slapping crap from a sketchbook or your kids scribblings up on RPGNow is not going to catapult you to fame and wealth. A little self-policing is a good thing. I am not proposing we institute some arbitrary quality standard; but I would suggest that quality will get you further than sheer quantity when it comes to stock art.
[End Rant]
Company Info
Categories
Where to Buy
BLOGROLL
ENWorld
Highmoon's Ponderings
Horrid Mischief
LPJ Design
OBS Publisher Forum
Otherverse Games
The Designer Monologues
THACO Shirts
Archives
Search
Meta
Comments RSS
Valid XHTML
XFN
WP